DeCorato Sheehan Merolesi & Federico, LLP, New York City Medical Malpractice Defense Attorneys

Practice Areas

  • Appellate Practice
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Guardianship and Nursing Home Litigation
  • Health Care Law, Professional Discipline & Regulation
  • Insurance Litigation
  • Matrimonial, Divorce and Family Law
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Product Liability and Medical Device
  • Tort, Catastrophic Damages and General Liability

Firm News

Defense Verdict for Orthopedist

In March of 2017, Timothy J. Sheehan obtained a directed verdict in a case of a then 44 year old woman who claimed that her orthopedic surgeon improperly treated her injured left shoulder. Plaintiff claimed her torn labrum should have been reattached (and not resected) and that she underwent an unnecessary manipulation under anesthesia, which she further claims led to two three additional operations and the development of a myriad of other spine and gait abnormalities that left her physically and emotionally crippled.   The defense maintained that the plaintiff had a serious “bucket handle” labral tear (which caused her shoulder to freeze) that could not be successfully reattached and that manipulation under anesthesia was the preferred method to regain optimal shoulder joint movement. The defense further argued that the plaintiff was the architect of her own post-op difficulties, as she abandoned a necessary physical therapy regimen, improperly immobilized her shoulder by placing her arm in a sling and underwent further procedures that were both unnecessary and unhelpful.  Plaintiff was initially represented by counsel, but before trial she elected to represent herself.  She did not call an expert witness and instead attempted to prove her claims by gamely calling the defendant to testify on her case.  Not surprisingly, the defendant, a prominent Manhattan orthopedist, ably defended his medical and surgical treatment.  Despite plaintiff’s emotional testimony to the jury – which featured her cross-country trips to undergo experimental forms of shoulder treatment and unsuccessful attempts to discern the cause for her balance and gait abnormalities – the trial Judge granted Mr. Sheehan’s dismissal motion at the end of plaintiff’s case for her failure to make out a prima facie case. (NY County Index No.:  103214/10)

Latest News at DSMF

COVID-19 PANDEMIC UPDATE »

Amanda L. Tate named DSMF Partner »

Amy T. Jen named DSMF Partner »

Kari A. Merolesi named Senior Partner »

Sheehan obtains Defense Verdict for Orthopedic Surgeon »

view all news items »

  • Home
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • News
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
DeCorato Sheehan Merolesi & Federico, LLP, New York City Medical Malpractice Defense Attorneys
Main Office: 90 Broad Street, 14th Floor, New York NY 10004, t: 212-742-8700, e: info@dsmflaw.com
Long Island Office: 1225 Franklin Avenue, Suite 325, Garden City, NY 11530
Copyright © 2022 DeCorato Sheehan Merolesi & Federico, LLP
This site may constitute Attorney Advertising